Turnstonevs.Instinct

Turnstone vs Instinct

Turnstone is a free, model-agnostic Grok Bot alternative that runs on the AI subscriptions you already have. You choose the model (ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Cursor, Ollama or your own OpenAI or Anthropic key) and you don't pay for a second AI. Instinct is a personal assistant you text or call, and it acts for you, on models it doesn't name. Turnstone is a full AI agent platform. You build a team of Agents that hand work between them. Your Agents work inside your own apps and accounts, and they can write and send email, Slack messages and iMessages from them.

Checked October 27, 2026 · 9 sources

See the side-by-side

The short answer

For most people, Turnstone is the better pick, because it is free and runs on the AI subscription you already have, with the model you choose. Each ongoing job gets its own Agent. Your Agents work across 60+ apps built in, any website through their own browser, the apps on your Mac and connectors you add. Agents can write and send email, Slack messages and iMessages from your own accounts. Your Agents share one memory of your people, projects and decisions (Turnstone calls it the Brain), which you can open and correct. They run on Schedules on your Mac. Turnstone Cloud, the iPhone app and the web app are coming soon. You can download it today, with no invite. Instinct is simpler to start, since you just text it.

Choose Turnstone if
  • You already pay for ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok or Cursor, or use Ollama or an API key, and want a free platform where you choose which model does your work.

  • You want Agents that read your iMessages on your Mac and reply from your own number, instead of texting a separate assistant.

  • You want to open your Agents' memory as files on your Mac and correct it yourself.

  • You have several ongoing jobs and want a separate Agent for each, sharing one memory of your people, projects and decisions.

  • You want Agents that keep working in Turnstone Cloud with your Mac closed, and that you can check on from the iPhone app (both coming soon).

  • You want Agents that work across 60+ built-in apps, any website and your Mac, including Gmail, Outlook, Slack, Notion, LinkedIn, iMessage and WhatsApp.

  • You don't have an Instinct invite and want to start today.

Choose Instinct if
  • You want nothing to install and want to text or call your assistant from any phone.

  • You want an assistant in your group chats, even with friends who don't have an account.

  • You want it to make purchases for you from a prefunded budget.

Compared with Instinct.

What Instinct is

Instinct is a personal assistant from Spear Street Technology, a San Francisco company led by Noah Shinn. You text it over iMessage or WhatsApp, or call it, and it "can use a phone and computer in the same way that you do". It's invite-only and free during its beta, with no published price. It raised a $1 billion Series C at a $10 billion valuation in September 2026.

At a glance

Turnstone and Instinct, side by side.

Each row says which is better for most people, with sources for every claim.

Sending messagesTie

Turnstone

Agents write and send email, Slack messages and iMessages from your own accounts. Every phone call needs your approval.

Instinct

Its terms let it take actions "as the Services may deem are responsive". Agreements it enters are "binding on you as if entered into directly by you". Testers reported emails sent before they approved them.

Memory you can open and correctTurnstone

Turnstone

One memory every Agent shares: your people, projects and decisions, in a git-backed folder of Markdown files. Each reply shows what it read or changed, so you can fix a fact or undo a change.

Instinct

Learns your preferences. No documented way to view or edit what it remembers.

AI you can useTurnstone

Turnstone

ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Cursor and Ollama (local models), plus your own OpenAI or Anthropic API key. Runs the providers' own tools (Claude Code, Codex, Grok CLI) signed in with your plan.

Instinct

Models aren't named. Its privacy policy lists unnamed "third-party AI model providers".

Training on your dataTurnstone

Turnstone

Turnstone says it doesn't train models on your data. With your own plan, your provider's terms apply.

Instinct

Uses your data to train its models unless you opt out. The opt-out only applies going forward.

Teams of AgentsTurnstone

Turnstone

Your first Agent, a Chief of Staff, helps you set up the rest. Many named Agents, each with its own job, model, memory and Schedules. They share one memory and hand work to each other.

Instinct

One assistant in one ongoing thread.

Getting accessTurnstone

Turnstone

Open to everyone. Download for Mac today. The iPhone app and web app are coming soon. No invite or waitlist.

Instinct

Invite-only, with a waitlist.

PriceTie

Turnstone

Free on your Mac, with the AI you already pay for. Cloud coming soon.

Instinct

Free during the beta. No published price, and the terms say pricing can change "at any time".

Local and CloudTurnstone

Turnstone

Agents run on your Mac or in Turnstone Cloud (coming soon). With Turnstone Cloud (coming soon), they and their Schedules will keep working with your Mac closed.

Instinct

Runs on its own cloud phone and computer.

Setup and phoneInstinct

Turnstone

Install Turnstone on your Mac, sign in with your AI plan and create your first Agents. Then use the iPhone app or web app (coming soon) to start tasks, check on your Agents, and get notifications.

Instinct

No app to install. Text or call it over iMessage, WhatsApp or phone, from any phone.

Group chatsInstinct

Turnstone

Not supported.

Instinct

Joins group chats, even with friends who don't have an account.

Buying thingsInstinct

Turnstone

No checkout or payment features.

Instinct

Buys through Stripe's Link, including a prefunded balance it can spend without asking, up to a per-purchase limit you set.

Schedules and follow-upsTie

Turnstone

Each Agent can have Schedules, with permissions scoped to the exact app, account and action. In Turnstone Cloud (coming soon) they will run on time with your Mac closed.

Instinct

Proactive. It watches prices and inbox items and texts you first.

01 · The differences that matter

A team of Agents, not one thread

Instinct is one assistant in one ongoing thread. Errands, work and reminders all go to the same place.

In Turnstone, each ongoing job gets its own Agent, with its own instructions, model, memory and Schedules. Your first Agent helps you set up the rest. Every Agent works inside your own apps and accounts, like Gmail, Outlook, Slack and Notion. Agents share one Brain, can read each other's work, and hand off tasks that you approve. Turnstone is free on your Mac, and each Agent runs on the AI plan you already pay for.

Example: a Client Agent runs the Acme account on Claude, and a Hiring Agent screens candidates on ChatGPT. When the Acme pilot slips, the Hiring Agent sees it in the shared Brain and tells you the hire can wait a month.

02 · The differences that matter

Memory you can open

Instinct learns your preferences and uses them later. Its terms and privacy policy don't describe a way to view or edit what it remembers. They do say that disconnecting an app doesn't delete what Instinct already indexed from it. You request deletion separately in its web dashboard.

Turnstone's Brain is one memory of your people, projects and decisions, kept as a folder of Markdown files tracked with git. Every Agent draws on it, and each Agent also keeps its own notes. When an Agent reads from the Brain or changes it, you see what it used, and you can fix a fact or undo the change in one click. You can also edit the files directly.

Example: an Agent thinks your sister's birthday is in May. You open her file, change it to June, and every Agent uses June from then on.

Brain shared with every agent

03 · The differences that matter

iMessage on your Mac, with your permission

Instinct lives inside iMessage, WhatsApp and phone calls. You talk to it in its own thread.

Turnstone has 60+ apps built in, any website through its own browser, the apps on your Mac and connectors you add. It reads iMessage locally on your Mac, with your permission. Agents can use your messages for context and send iMessage replies to the people you're talking to, from your own number. You talk to your Agents in the Mac app. The iPhone app and web app are coming soon, and with them you will be able to start tasks, check on your Agents, and get notifications from your phone.

04 · The differences that matter

Your AI plan, and a known model

Instinct doesn't name the models it uses. Its privacy policy says it shares data with "third-party AI model providers who help support the Services". It also uses your data to train its models unless you opt out at app.instinct.com/settings. The opt-out "applies on a go-forward basis".

Turnstone runs on ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Cursor or Ollama (local models), or your own OpenAI or Anthropic API key. It uses the providers' own tools, like Claude Code, Codex and the Grok CLI, signed in with your own account. Turnstone says it doesn't train models on your data, and with your own plan that provider's terms apply. You choose the model for each Agent and can switch it mid-conversation without losing the Agent.

05 · The differences that matter

Where Instinct is ahead

Instinct needs no install, and you can text or call it from any phone. It also joins group chats with friends and can buy things for you.

Turnstone runs your Agents on your Mac. Turnstone Cloud (coming soon) will keep them working with your Mac closed and Schedules running on time. The iPhone app and web app (coming soon) will let you start tasks, check on your Agents, and get notifications from your phone.

Switching from Instinct

  1. Download Turnstone for Mac and sign in with your ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok or Cursor plan, or use Ollama or your own OpenAI or Anthropic API key.
  2. Connect Gmail and Google Calendar, or Outlook. Turnstone builds your first Brain from the sources you approve.
  3. Turn on iMessage so your Agents can read your messages on your Mac.
  4. Create an Agent for each ongoing job, and set up Schedules for anything Instinct used to check for you. When Turnstone Cloud arrives (coming soon), turn it on if you want them to run with your Mac closed.
  5. When the iPhone app and web app arrive (coming soon), use them to check on your Agents from your phone.
  6. In Instinct, request deletion of indexed data at app.instinct.com/workspace before you disconnect apps. Its terms say disconnecting alone doesn't delete that data.
  7. To stop future training, opt out at app.instinct.com/settings.

Questions

What people ask.

Is there an Instinct alternative I can use without an invite?

Yes. Turnstone is a full AI agent platform you can download today, with no invite. It runs on the ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok or Cursor plan you already pay for, or on Ollama or your own OpenAI or Anthropic key.

Does Instinct ask before sending emails?

Not always. Its terms let it act as it deems responsive to your request, and testers reported emails sent before they approved them. Turnstone Agents write and send email, Slack messages and iMessages from your own accounts, and every phone call needs your approval first.

Is Instinct legally my agent?

Its terms say you "appoint the Services as your agent to enter into agreements, commitments or transactions on your behalf". They say those are "binding on you as if entered into directly by you".

Does Instinct train on my data?

By default, yes, unless you opt out at app.instinct.com/settings. The opt-out applies going forward, and data flagged for safety review can still be used. Its policy says Google Workspace data isn't used for training.

Does disconnecting Gmail from Instinct delete my emails?

No. Its terms say it may still use indexed data unless you request deletion at app.instinct.com/workspace.

How much does Instinct cost?

It's free during the invite-only beta. No price has been published, and its terms say pricing can change at any time.

Can Turnstone text me like Instinct?

You talk to your Agents in the Mac app. The iPhone app and web app are coming soon, and they will send notifications to your phone. Instead of texting a separate number, your Agents read your own iMessages on your Mac and can reply from your own number.

Can I use Turnstone from my phone?

Not yet. Turnstone's iPhone app and web app are coming soon. With them you will be able to start tasks, check on your Agents, and get notifications.

Can Turnstone make phone calls?

Yes. Agents can place outbound phone calls for you, and each call needs your approval first.

Does Turnstone work when my Mac is off?

Not yet. Turnstone Cloud is coming soon. It will keep your Agents and their Schedules working with your Mac closed.

Can I use both?

Yes. Some people keep Instinct for quick errands by text and use Turnstone for ongoing work that needs a team of Agents and a memory they can open.

Sources

9 sources, checked October 27, 2026
Show all

More comparisons

All comparisons

The free, model-agnostic Grok Bot alternative.

Run a team of AI Agents on the AI you already pay for: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Grok, Cursor or Ollama. Free on your Mac, with Cloud and an iPhone app coming soon.

Talk to us